
The EU’s highest court has refused to say whether Malta’s Bill 55 complies with EU law. It threw out an Austrian court’s request as inadmissible, so one of Europe’s most closely watched gambling disputes stays open.
In the court’s view, the Vienna judges could settle their case without an answer on Bill 55. That case was about a lawyer’s liability, not about player losses. The ruling came on Thursday, according to iGaming Business.
What is Bill 55?
Bill 55 put a new provision into Malta’s Gaming Act in 2023. It stops Maltese courts from recognising and enforcing certain judgments from other EU countries against Malta-licensed operators. CasinoBeats reported that Malta’s government defended it as declaratory, a way of helping Maltese courts use the public policy ground in Article 45(1)(a) of the Brussels I bis Regulation.
Critics say it lets operators dodge judgments won by players in other member states. Focus Gaming News noted that regulators and player advocates across Europe objected to it from the start. Malta answers that the law fits the EU principles of free movement and freedom to provide services.
Why did the court say no?
The Commercial Court of Vienna made the referral in 2024. It grew out of a claim by Spielerschutz Sigma, an Austrian litigation funder, against a legal adviser. CasinoBeats reported that the adviser’s opinion, dated 5 July 2023, called Article 56A manifestly contrary to EU law. It also predicted that first-instance enforcement in Malta would wrap up within six months.
It did not work out that way. On 1 August 2023 a Maltese court invoked Article 56A to deny recognition and enforcement of an Austrian judgment. Spielerschutz Sigma funded those proceedings and then sued the adviser for professional negligence.
The EU court held that this dispute called for no interpretation of EU law. Terence Cassar, a partner at the Maltese law firm GTG, told iGaming Business:
It was very clear that the underlying case from which the referral was presented. This was essentially a legal malpractice lawsuit.
Terence Cassar, partner, GTG
Felix Hohenthanner of Rapani Rechtsanwälte said the outcome was expected. He called it a procedural decision.
What does it mean for operators and players?
For MGA licensees with business in Germany, Austria and Switzerland, CasinoBeats said little changes in practice. Maltese courts remain free to decline to enforce Austrian and German judgments that order operators to repay losses. Players in Germany are also pursuing claims, as SBC News noted.
Hohenthanner told iGaming Business that recovery is getting harder for Austrian players: “Unless there are any other assets in other European countries, it’s getting harder and harder for players to get their funds.”
Two other rulings touch the same conflict, CasinoBeats said. In Case C-440/23, decided on 16 April 2026, the court found that a member state can prohibit some online gambling services licensed in another EU country, and can link civil-law consequences to that prohibition. The Mr Green ruling (C-198/24), issued on 21 May 2026, said that a court judging urgency may take into account a law in the debtor’s home state that could get in the way of enforcement.
What happens next?
Two routes could still produce an answer. CasinoBeats said the European Commission’s infringement case against Malta remains open. The Commission’s argument is that the law requires Maltese courts, as a general rule, to reject other member states’ judgments against Malta-licensed gaming firms. With no ruling from Luxembourg, any escalation now rests with the Commission.
The other route is a fresh referral. iGaming Business reported that Malta’s Court of Appeal sent questions on Bill 55 to the EU court in October. Hohenthanner thinks that case could bring a ruling on the merits, “maybe in 2027, maybe a little bit more.”
Simon Priglinger-Simader, who heads the Austrian Association for Betting and Gaming, called the decision “understandable from an EU law perspective”. He said the association will keep following the proceedings.





